A new decision of the New York Appellate Division, First Department, in Matter of Giurdanella, 2026 NY Slip Op 06234 (1st Dep’t Decided Oct. 22, 2026), is noteworthy for three distinct reasons: (1) the Court expounded upon a subject not often explained—when and under what circumstances issues can be considered on appeal even though not raised in the court below, also known as the “preservation doctrine”; (2) the Court considered what it described as an issue of first impression—whether the doctrine of equitable estoppel can prevent parties in an estate dispute from relying upon the time limitations in the New York Estates, Powers & Trusts Law (EPTL) to bar an untimely notice of spousal election that those parties allegedly caused the spouse to miss; and (3) the majority and dissenting judges on this Appellate Panel were particularly passionate in debating the issues, using rather strong language of advocacy.
Spousal Election
EPTL 5-1.1-A(a)(2) explains that a surviving spouse has a right to an “elective share” of the deceased spouse’s estate, defined as follows: “The elective share, as used in this paragraph, is the pecuniary amount equal to the greater of (i) fifty thousand dollars or, if the capital value of the net estate is less than fifty thousand dollars, such capital value, or (ii) one third of the net estate.” There is a deadline by which the surviving spouse must make this election, as set forth in EPTL 5-1.1-A(d)(1): “An election under this section must be made within six months from the date of issuance of letters testamentary or of administration, as the case may be, but in no event later than two years after the date of decedent’s death, except as otherwise provided in subparagraph 2 of this paragraph.” Apart from circumstances allowed in the referenced subparagraph 2, EPLT 5-1.1-A(d)(3) provides: “The time limited in this paragraph for making an election is exclusive and shall not be suspended or otherwise affected by any provision of law, except that the surrogate may, in his or her discretion, permit an election to be made in behalf of an infant or incompetent spouse at any time up to, but no later than, the entry of the decree of the first judicial account of the representative of the estate, made more than seven months after the issuance of letters.”
990 Stewart Avenue, Suite 300,
Garden City, NY 11530
750 Ninth Street, Suite 501
Washington, D.C. 20001
Phone(202) 887-6726Fax:(202) 223-0358